top of page
Search

Why Some Epagneul Bretons Retrieve

Writer: Joel Ebstein
Joel Ebstein
5 minutes ago
6 min read

If you have ever watched two Epagneul Bretons work the same field, you may have noticed something curious. One dog finds a bird, holds a beautiful point, and when the bird falls, trots back with it held gently in her mouth. The other dog points just as well, but when the bird falls, she runs to it, sniffs it, and wanders off to look for the next one. Both dogs are good hunters. Only one of them retrieves.


Retrieving is one of the most misunderstood parts of the Epagneul Breton's job. Owners assume it comes along with the pointing instinct, or that a dog who will not retrieve is stubborn or poorly trained. The truth is more interesting. Retrieving has its own history in the breed, its own instincts, and its own training path, and understanding it will change how you work with your dog.


Retrieving Is Part of the Job


The Epagneul Breton was developed as a dog that could do the whole job: find game, point it, and bring it back to the hunter. In Brittany, France, hunters worked small fields and thick cover, often on foot and often alone. A dog that could find birds in dense brambles and then carry them back through wet ground was worth keeping, and dogs that would not bring birds back were less useful no matter how well they pointed.


That history still shows in the breed today. Most Epagneul Bretons have at least some desire to pick things up and carry them. Puppies carry shoes, socks, and toys around the house. That carrying instinct is the raw material of a retrieve. But carrying a sock around the living room and carrying a warm bird back across a field are two very different tasks, and the gap between them is where training comes in.


Why Some Dogs Retrieve and Others Do Not


Several things shape whether a dog retrieves naturally. The first is the desire to carry. Some dogs are born with a strong urge to hold things in their mouths. They pick up everything and they do not want to let go. Other dogs are less interested in carrying and more interested in finding the next bird. Neither dog is wrong. They simply have different strengths.


The second is softness of mouth. A good retrieving dog holds a bird firmly enough to carry it and gently enough not to damage it. Dogs vary in this, and a dog that mouths birds hard or drops them repeatedly may be telling you something about how the bird feels in her mouth rather than about her willingness.


The third is confidence. A nervous dog may find a fallen bird exciting but also uncertain, and uncertainty often looks like avoidance. She runs to the bird, then runs away from it, or circles it without picking it up. Building confidence around birds and around the retrieve itself often matters more than drilling repetitions.


Early experience matters too. A puppy that is chased every time she picks something up learns a clear lesson: holding things leads to being chased, so it is better to run away with the prize or drop it and move on. Many retrieve problems in adult dogs trace back to games in the house that accidentally taught the dog the wrong lesson.


Natural Retrieve Versus Trained Retrieve


There is a real difference between a dog that retrieves because she wants to and a dog that retrieves because she has learned a reliable sequence. A natural retriever will go out, pick up the bird, and come back with little formal training. A trained retriever may start with less natural desire but ends up just as dependable because each part of the job has been taught clearly: go out on command, pick up the bird, hold it, come back, and deliver it to hand.


Some trainers use a method called force fetch to build a trained retrieve. It teaches the dog to pick up and hold on command through careful, structured pressure and release. It is a legitimate training method in experienced hands, but it requires good timing, patience, and an understanding of the individual dog. It is not something to attempt casually, and it is not necessary for every dog. Many Epagneul Bretons become fine retrievers through patient, reward based work alone, and a heavy handed approach can damage a sensitive dog's enthusiasm for birds.


The question is not which method is correct in the abstract. The question is what your individual dog needs. A bold puppy with a strong carrying instinct may need almost no formal retrieve training at all. A softer dog may need the retrieve built slowly, piece by piece, with no pressure at all until she is confident.


Building a Reliable Retrieve


If you are starting retrieve training with a young Epagneul Breton, keep it simple and keep it fun. Start in a hallway or a small yard where the dog cannot run a long way from you. Use a small canvas dummy or a rolled up sock. Toss it a short distance, let the dog pick it up, and then encourage her back to you. When she arrives, trade for a treat rather than prying the object from her mouth. The trade teaches her that coming back to you with the object is the rewarding part of the game.


Keep sessions short, just a few retrieves at a time, and stop while the dog still wants more. Ending on a success builds enthusiasm for the next session. Long sessions with many repetitions tend to bore a young dog, and a bored dog starts dropping dummies, wandering off, or losing interest in the game altogether.


Never chase a dog that runs away with a dummy. Chasing turns the retrieve into a game of keep away, and it is a game the dog will win every time. If she runs off, stay calm, turn away, and wait. Many dogs will come back on their own once the chase stops being fun. If she keeps running off, go back to a smaller space and shorter tosses until the habit is solid.


Build up to birds gradually. A dummy is easy to hold and easy to carry. A bird is warm, soft, and strange, and some dogs need time to get comfortable with it. Dead birds, used in training, are the usual next step, and only when the dog is confident with those should she be asked to retrieve a freshly shot bird in the field. Rushing this step is one of the most common reasons a dog that retrieves dummies well will not retrieve game.


Water Retrieves Deserve Their Own Lesson


Many Epagneul Bretons love water, but a water retrieve asks more of a dog than a land retrieve does. There is cold water, current, uncertain footing, and a bird that may be drifting away. A dog that retrieves confidently on land may hesitate at the water's edge, and that hesitation is normal.


Build water retrieves the same way you built land retrieves: in small steps. Let the dog wade in shallow water first and get comfortable. Toss a dummy just a few feet from the bank so the swim is short and the return is easy. Choose warm days and calm water for early lessons. Never throw a young dog into water or push her in from a bank. A frightening first experience at water can take a long time to undo.


When a Dog Will Not Retrieve


Some dogs never become reliable retrievers, even with patient training. That can be disappointing, especially when you have watched other dogs in the field bring birds back beautifully. But it is worth saying plainly: a dog that points well, handles kindly, and hunts with enthusiasm is still a fine hunting companion. Hunting over a dog that points well and lets you walk in to pick up the bird is still good hunting.


If your dog will not retrieve, it is worth checking the basics first. Is she confident around birds? Has she been chased or corrected for picking things up? Is she being asked to retrieve in situations that are too difficult for her current level? Sometimes the fix is simpler than it looks, and sometimes the answer is to accept the dog you have and enjoy the hunting she does well.


The Retrieve Completes the Hunt


A good retrieve is satisfying to watch because it is the end of a sequence that started with the dog finding the bird. Search, point, flush, shot, retrieve. Each part matters, and the retrieve is the part that brings the whole effort back to your hand.


Whether your Epagneul Breton retrieves naturally or needs the job built slowly, the same principles apply: keep it positive, keep sessions short, build in small steps, and pay attention to what your individual dog is telling you. The dogs that retrieve best are usually the ones that were given time to enjoy it.


If you are working through retrieve training with a young Epagneul Breton, take your time with it. The pointing instinct may come built in, but the retrieve is a partnership, and partnerships take a little patience to build. That is part of what makes the breed so rewarding to hunt over.

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Why Your Epagneul Breton Barks

If you live with an Epagneul Breton, you already know the voice. It is sharp, fast, and hard to ignore, and it can show up at the doorbell, at a squirrel, at a guest, or at absolutely nothing you can

 
 
 
How France Tests the Epagneul Breton

In the United States, a hunting dog can earn titles in the field and ribbons in the show ring, and the two worlds rarely meet. In France, the home of the Epagneul Breton, the two worlds are part of on

 
 
 
Teaching Your Epagneul Breton to Honor

Teaching Your Epagneul Breton to Honor Picture a morning hunt with a friend. His dog locks up on point fifty yards ahead in the brush. Your Epagneul Breton spots the other dog, and in that instant eve

 
 
 

Comments


CaliBretons Kennel

  • Instagram

©2025 by California Gun Dogs. California French Brittanys

bottom of page